In short: Replace the tub if you bathe in it or keep one for young children; convert to a low-curb or curbless shower if daily ease of entry matters more. Either way, settle shower dimensions, threshold height, drain location, waterproofing and fixture flow before choosing tile. San Pedro is in the City of Los Angeles, so permits go through LADBS, not the County.
Bathtub replacement in San Pedro rarely stays a simple swap. Pull out an old tub and a series of questions follows: what goes back in its place, a new tub, a larger shower, or a low-curb or curbless walk-in? The order in which you answer those questions shapes everything that comes after, from the drain to the last row of tile. This guide walks through the decisions in the sequence our design-build team uses, so the finishes you fall in love with are built on a plan that actually works.
Replace the Tub or Convert to a Shower?
The first decision is not material or style. It is how the bathroom will be used for the next decade or longer. A hall bath shared with young children works differently from a primary suite where two adults shower every morning, and both differ from a bathroom planned for aging in place.
What national data shows about bathrooms in 2026
Homeowners across the country are weighing the same tradeoff. In Houzz’s 2026 U.S. Bathroom Trends Study, 38% of renovating homeowners upgraded their bathtub and 8% kept the existing one, while 26% of bathroom projects removed a tub altogether. Of those removing a tub, 79% used the space to enlarge the shower. Houzz’s October 2026 report, The Bathroom Features Homeowners Want Most in 2026, found that 49% of renovating homeowners enlarged their shower, up 10 percentage points, and 47% of those upgrading showers chose low-curb designs.
Those numbers are useful context, not a verdict. What matters is your household, your floor plan and how many tubs will remain in the home after the project.
When keeping a tub still makes sense
A tub remains the practical choice when it is the only one in the house and you bathe small children or pets, when someone in the household soaks regularly for recovery or simple ritual, or when you expect future buyers to look for at least one tub. Many South Bay homeowners land on a split approach: a soaking tub or tub and shower combination in the hall bath, and a generous walk-in shower in the primary suite.
Bathtub refinishing versus full replacement
If your existing tub is structurally sound and the right size, refinishing can refresh a worn surface. It is a surface treatment, though. It does not fix a tub that flexes underfoot, leaks at the drain, sits in the wrong place for your layout or hides water damage in the subfloor beneath it. Full replacement makes sense when the tub is cracked or chipped through, when the surrounding tile and waterproofing are failing, or when you are changing the room. A practical test: if you plan to retile the surround anyway, replacing the tub at the same time avoids tearing out brand new tile later to reach an old tub.
If You Keep a Tub: Materials, Styles and Sizes
Acrylic, fiberglass, cast iron and porcelain-enameled steel
Each material behaves differently in daily use, and the right one depends on how you bathe and where the tub will sit.
- Acrylic bathtubs: Formed acrylic over a reinforced backing. Lightweight, warm to the touch and available in a wide range of shapes. In Houzz’s 2025 U.S. Bathroom Trends Study, acrylic was the most frequently chosen tub material, selected by 60% of renovating homeowners. Light surface scratches can often be polished out.
- Fiberglass bathtubs: Molded fiberglass with a gelcoat finish. Light and easy to maneuver into tight bathrooms, but the finish is thinner and more prone to dulling, flexing and hairline cracks over time.
- Cast-iron bathtubs: Iron coated in porcelain enamel. Exceptionally durable and heat retaining, with a deep, glossy finish. They are also very heavy, so floor framing, the path through the house and the size of the install crew all need to be considered, especially on a second floor.
- Porcelain-enameled steel bathtubs: Stamped steel with an enamel coating. More rigid than fiberglass and lighter than cast iron, with a classic glossy surface, though the enamel can chip on impact and the thinner metal gives up heat faster.
There is no single best bathtub material. Acrylic suits most remodels for its balance of comfort, weight and design range. Cast iron rewards people who soak often and value longevity. Fiberglass and enameled steel fit specific situations where weight or tight access drives the decision.
Alcove, freestanding and soaking tubs
Alcove tubs sit between three walls and usually double as a shower. Freestanding tubs stand on the floor as a sculptural piece and need clearance around them, plus a floor-mounted or wall-mounted filler. Soaking tubs are defined by depth rather than shape and can be alcove, drop-in or freestanding. Houzz’s 2026 study found that 72% of homeowners adding or replacing a tub chose a soaking tub, and 57% selected a freestanding flat-bottom style. Keep in mind that a freestanding tub changes the plumbing more than any other option, because the drain and supply lines usually move out into the room.
What size bathtub fits a standard alcove
The common alcove is 60 inches long, with tubs typically 30 or 32 inches wide. Deeper soaking versions of that footprint exist, which lets you upgrade comfort without moving walls. Measure the finished opening wall to wall, check whether the walls are out of square and note the drain side. Alcove tubs are sold as left-hand or right-hand drain, and matching your existing side is the simplest way to keep plumbing changes to a minimum.
Converting a Tub to a Shower: Decide These Before Tile
Tub-to-shower conversions are where planning order matters most. Tile is the most visible choice, so it is tempting to start there. But the slope, drain style, curb and waterproofing system determine which tile sizes and layouts will actually perform. Settle these first, and tile selection becomes a pleasure instead of a compromise.
Shower dimensions and threshold height
Converting a standard 60-inch alcove usually yields a shower about five feet wide and roughly as deep as the old tub, comfortably above the California Plumbing Code minimum of 1,024 square inches of floor area with room for a 30-inch circle. If the floor plan allows, borrowing a few inches from an adjacent closet or vanity wall can make the shower feel far more generous and help contain splash.
Threshold height comes next. A low-curb shower keeps a short, shallow curb that holds water in while making entry much easier than stepping over a tub wall. A curbless shower removes the curb entirely, so the shower floor must sit lower than the bathroom floor to carry water to the drain. That usually means recessing the subfloor or building up the surrounding floor. On a raised foundation, joists may need to be modified; on a slab, concrete may need to be cut. Neither is a reason to avoid curbless design, but both need to be understood before the plan is final.
Drain location and whether plumbing moves
Code requires a shower floor to slope toward the drain at no less than a quarter inch per foot. A center drain needs the floor to slope from four directions, which generally calls for smaller tile or mosaic that can follow the angles. A linear drain along the back wall or entry lets the floor slope in a single plane, opening the door to large-format tile and a cleaner, continuous look. That is why the drain decision has to come before tile.
Can you replace a bathtub without changing the plumbing? For a like-for-like alcove tub with the same drain side, often yes, though the drain assembly and shower valve are commonly updated at the same time. A conversion almost always involves relocating or replacing the drain, and a freestanding tub nearly always moves supply and drain lines.
Waterproofing and fixture flow limits
A tub is a waterproof vessel by design. A shower floor is not; it becomes waterproof only through the system beneath the tile, whether a sheet membrane, a liquid-applied membrane or a traditional mortar bed with a liner. Low-curb and curbless showers ask more of that system because water travels closer to the bathroom floor, and a flood test before tile is a sensible checkpoint. In San Pedro’s marine air, a properly sized exhaust fan matters as well.
Fixtures belong in the plan early too. California caps showerhead flow at 1.8 gallons per minute, and CALGreen limits combined flow when a shower has more than one outlet unless each is designed to run one at a time. That shapes any plan for rain heads, handshowers and body sprays. Valve type, niche placement, bench location and blocking for future grab bars should all be decided before the walls close.
Do You Need a Permit to Replace a Bathtub in San Pedro?
Why San Pedro uses LADBS, not the County
San Pedro is part of the City of Los Angeles, so permits run through the Los Angeles Department of Building and Safety (LADBS), not Los Angeles County Building and Safety, which runs a separate process primarily for unincorporated areas. Neighboring cities such as Torrance, Redondo Beach, Manhattan Beach, Rancho Palos Verdes, Palos Verdes Estates and Long Beach each have their own building departments, so requirements and processes can differ from one side of a city line to the other.
Plumbing permits, building permits and express permits
LADBS guidance states that bathtub installation or plumbing alterations require a plumbing permit, and related floor, subfloor or wall repairs may also require a building permit. LADBS also lists nonstructural residential kitchen and bath remodels among express-permit projects, including through its San Pedro office. Whether a given project qualifies depends on scope. Modifying joists for a curbless shower or moving a wall can change the picture, so confirm requirements with LADBS before work begins.
Cost and Schedule: What Shapes Both
What drives bathtub replacement cost in San Pedro
There is no honest single number, because two projects both called bathtub replacement can differ enormously in scope. The main drivers are whether the work is a same-footprint swap or a conversion, tub material and weight, whether plumbing moves, the condition of the subfloor and framing once the old tub is out, the waterproofing system, tile size and pattern, glass and permit requirements. A detailed scope reviewed in person is the only reliable basis for pricing.
What shapes how long bathtub replacement takes
Schedule follows the same choices. Special-order tubs and fixtures carry lead times. Hidden water damage discovered at demolition adds repair work. Plumbing changes and inspections must be sequenced, waterproofing should be tested before tile, and custom glass is typically measured only after tile is complete. Finalizing every selection up front, down to the trim kit, is the most effective way to keep a project moving.
Planning with a single design-build team
Verity Kitchen & Bath is a family-owned, fully licensed design-build firm with more than 15 years in business and over 1,000 completed projects. One team carries a bathroom from design through construction, which keeps decisions about drains, curbs and waterproofing connected to the finishes you choose. We serve San Pedro and the South Bay communities of Torrance, Redondo Beach, Manhattan Beach, Palos Verdes and Long Beach, and you are welcome to explore materials at our showroom in Torrance. Learn more about our bathroom remodeling process or get to know our family-owned team.
Weighing a new tub against a low-curb or curbless shower? Schedule a consultation and we will walk through your space, your priorities and every decision that should come before tile.
Questions homeowners ask
How much does bathtub replacement cost in San Pedro?
Cost depends on scope rather than a single rate. A same-footprint alcove tub swap, a freestanding tub that moves plumbing and a curbless shower conversion are very different projects. Tub material, subfloor condition, waterproofing, tile, glass and permits all shape the final figure, so an in-person review of the space is the reliable starting point.
Do I need a permit to replace a bathtub in San Pedro?
Generally yes. San Pedro is in the City of Los Angeles, and LADBS guidance states that bathtub installation or plumbing alterations require a plumbing permit, with related floor, subfloor or wall repairs possibly requiring a building permit. LADBS lists nonstructural residential bath remodels among express-permit projects, including through its San Pedro office.
How long does bathtub replacement take?
Timing depends on scope. Lead times on tubs and fixtures, hidden damage found at demolition, plumbing changes, inspections, waterproofing tests and custom glass all shape the schedule. Finalizing every selection before work begins helps keep it on track.
Can I replace my bathtub without changing the plumbing?
Often, if you install a same-size alcove tub with the drain on the same side. The drain assembly and valve are frequently updated anyway. Freestanding tubs and tub-to-shower conversions usually require moving or replacing the drain and supply lines.
Is it better to replace or refinish a bathtub?
Refinishing can refresh a sound tub that is the right size. Replacement is the better choice when the tub is cracked, flexes or leaks, or when you are retiling, changing the layout or addressing water damage underneath.
What is the best bathtub material: acrylic, fiberglass, or cast iron?
Acrylic balances warmth, weight and design range and was the most chosen material in Houzz’s 2025 U.S. Bathroom Trends Study at 60%. Cast iron offers durability and heat retention but is very heavy. Fiberglass is light but less durable. Porcelain-enameled steel sits between them.
Can I replace my bathtub with a walk-in shower?
Yes. A standard alcove converts well to a low-curb or curbless shower. Settle shower size, threshold height, drain location, waterproofing and fixture flow before choosing tile, and keep at least one tub in the home if your household needs it.
What size bathtub fits a standard alcove?
The common alcove tub is 60 inches long and 30 or 32 inches wide. Measure the finished opening, check for out-of-square walls and match the existing drain side to limit plumbing changes.
